Carl Shulman (Pt 2) — AI Takeover, bio & cyber attacks, detecting deception, & humanity's far future

Dwarkesh Patel · Beginner ·🛡️ AI Safety & Ethics ·2y ago
The second half of my 7 hour conversation with Carl Shulman is out! My favorite part! And the one that had the biggest impact on my worldview. Here, Carl lays out how an AI takeover might happen: * AI can threaten mutually assured destruction from bioweapons, * use cyber attacks to take over physical infrastructure, * build mechanical armies, * spread seed AIs we can never exterminate, * offer tech and other advantages to collaborating countries, etc Plus we talk about a whole bunch of weird and interesting topics which Carl has thought about: * what is the far future best case scenario for humanity * what it would look like to have AI make thousands of years of intellectual progress in a month * how do we detect deception in superhuman models * does space warfare favor defense or offense * is a Malthusian state inevitable in the long run * why markets haven't priced in explosive economic growth * & much more Carl also explains how he developed such a rigorous, thoughtful, and interdisciplinary model of the biggest problems in the world. 𝐄𝐏𝐈𝐒𝐎𝐃𝐄 𝐋𝐈𝐍𝐊𝐒 * Catch part 1 here: https://youtu.be/_kRg-ZP1vQc * Transcript: https://www.dwarkeshpatel.com/carl-shulman-2 * Apple Podcasts: https://bit.ly/3r1HBJk * Spotify: https://bit.ly/437t50c * Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/dwarkesh_sp * Carl's blog: http://reflectivedisequilibrium.blogspot.com/ 𝐒𝐏𝐎𝐍𝐒𝐎𝐑𝐒 This episode is sponsored by 80,000 hours. To get their free career guide (and to help out this podcast), please visit 80000hours.org/lunar. 𝐓𝐈𝐌𝐄𝐒𝐓𝐀𝐌𝐏𝐒 00:00:00 - Intro 00:00:47 - AI takeover via cyber or bio 00:32:27 - Can we coordinate against AI? 00:53:49 - Human vs AI colonizers 01:04:55 - Probability of AI takeover 01:21:56 - Can we detect deception? 01:47:25 - Using AI to solve coordination problems 01:56:01 - Partial alignment 02:11:41 - AI far future 02:23:04 - Markets & other evidence 02:33:26 - Day in the life of Carl Shulman 02:47:05 - Space warfare, Malthusian long
Watch on YouTube ↗ (saves to browser)
Sign in to unlock AI tutor explanation · ⚡30

Playlist

Uploads from Dwarkesh Patel · Dwarkesh Patel · 0 of 60

← Previous Next →
1 Rubik's Cube Encryption Demo
Rubik's Cube Encryption Demo
Dwarkesh Patel
2 Bryan Caplan - Nurturing Orphaned Ideas, Education, and UBI
Bryan Caplan - Nurturing Orphaned Ideas, Education, and UBI
Dwarkesh Patel
3 Matjaž Leonardis - Science, Identity and Probability
Matjaž Leonardis - Science, Identity and Probability
Dwarkesh Patel
4 Robin Hanson - The Long View and The Elephant in the Brain
Robin Hanson - The Long View and The Elephant in the Brain
Dwarkesh Patel
5 Caleb Watney - America's Innovation Engine
Caleb Watney - America's Innovation Engine
Dwarkesh Patel
6 Alex Tabarrok - Prizes, Prices, and Public Goods
Alex Tabarrok - Prizes, Prices, and Public Goods
Dwarkesh Patel
7 Scott Young - Ultralearning, The MIT Challenge
Scott Young - Ultralearning, The MIT Challenge
Dwarkesh Patel
8 Scott Aaronson - Quantum Computing, Complexity, and Creativity
Scott Aaronson - Quantum Computing, Complexity, and Creativity
Dwarkesh Patel
9 Uncle Bob - The Long Reach of Code, Automating Programming, and Developing Coding Talent
Uncle Bob - The Long Reach of Code, Automating Programming, and Developing Coding Talent
Dwarkesh Patel
10 Michael Huemer - Anarchy, Capitalism, and Progress
Michael Huemer - Anarchy, Capitalism, and Progress
Dwarkesh Patel
11 Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
Sarah Fitz-Claridge - Taking Children Seriously | The Lunar Society #15
Dwarkesh Patel
12 Byrne Hobart - Optionality, Stagnation, and Secret Societies
Byrne Hobart - Optionality, Stagnation, and Secret Societies
Dwarkesh Patel
13 David Deutsch - AI, America, Fun, & Bayes
David Deutsch - AI, America, Fun, & Bayes
Dwarkesh Patel
14 Bryan Caplan - Labor Econ, Poverty, & Mental Illness
Bryan Caplan - Labor Econ, Poverty, & Mental Illness
Dwarkesh Patel
15 Jimmy Soni - Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, and the Paypal Mafia
Jimmy Soni - Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, and the Paypal Mafia
Dwarkesh Patel
16 Razib Khan - Genomics, Intelligence, and The Church of Science
Razib Khan - Genomics, Intelligence, and The Church of Science
Dwarkesh Patel
17 Pradyu Prasad - Imperial Japan, the God Emperor, and Militarization in the Modern World
Pradyu Prasad - Imperial Japan, the God Emperor, and Militarization in the Modern World
Dwarkesh Patel
18 Manifold Markets Founder - Predictions Markets & Revolutionizing Governance
Manifold Markets Founder - Predictions Markets & Revolutionizing Governance
Dwarkesh Patel
19 Ananyo Bhattacharya - John von Neumann, Jewish Genius, and Nuclear War
Ananyo Bhattacharya - John von Neumann, Jewish Genius, and Nuclear War
Dwarkesh Patel
20 Agustin Lebron - Trading, Crypto, and Adverse Selection
Agustin Lebron - Trading, Crypto, and Adverse Selection
Dwarkesh Patel
21 Sam Bankman-Fried - Crypto, FTX, Altruism, & Leadership
Sam Bankman-Fried - Crypto, FTX, Altruism, & Leadership
Dwarkesh Patel
22 Alexander Mikaberidze - Napoleon, War, Progress, and Global Order
Alexander Mikaberidze - Napoleon, War, Progress, and Global Order
Dwarkesh Patel
23 Sam Bankman-Fried On FOCUS
Sam Bankman-Fried On FOCUS
Dwarkesh Patel
24 Sam Bankman-Fried on GREAT FOUNDERS
Sam Bankman-Fried on GREAT FOUNDERS
Dwarkesh Patel
25 $30 BILLION Opportunity Ignored by Sam Bankman-Fried Competitors
$30 BILLION Opportunity Ignored by Sam Bankman-Fried Competitors
Dwarkesh Patel
26 Fin Moorhouse - Longtermism, Space, & Entrepreneurship
Fin Moorhouse - Longtermism, Space, & Entrepreneurship
Dwarkesh Patel
27 Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
Joseph Carlsmith - Utopia, AI, & Infinite Ethics
Dwarkesh Patel
28 Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Effective Altruism, History, & Technology
Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Effective Altruism, History, & Technology
Dwarkesh Patel
29 Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity
Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity
Dwarkesh Patel
30 Austin Vernon - Energy Superabundance, Starship Missiles, & Finding Alpha
Austin Vernon - Energy Superabundance, Starship Missiles, & Finding Alpha
Dwarkesh Patel
31 Charles C. Mann - Americas Before Columbus & Scientific Wizardry
Charles C. Mann - Americas Before Columbus & Scientific Wizardry
Dwarkesh Patel
32 Tyler Cowen - Why Society Will Collapse & Why Sex is Pessimistic
Tyler Cowen - Why Society Will Collapse & Why Sex is Pessimistic
Dwarkesh Patel
33 Bryan Caplan - Feminists, Billionaires, and Demagogues
Bryan Caplan - Feminists, Billionaires, and Demagogues
Dwarkesh Patel
34 Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review
Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review
Dwarkesh Patel
35 Kenneth T. Jackson - Robert Moses, Hero of New York?
Kenneth T. Jackson - Robert Moses, Hero of New York?
Dwarkesh Patel
36 Edward Glaeser - Cities, Terrorism, Housing, & Remote Work
Edward Glaeser - Cities, Terrorism, Housing, & Remote Work
Dwarkesh Patel
37 Byrne Hobart - FTX, Drugs, Twitter, Taiwan, & Monasticism
Byrne Hobart - FTX, Drugs, Twitter, Taiwan, & Monasticism
Dwarkesh Patel
38 Nadia Asparouhova — Tech elites, democracy, open source, & philanthropy
Nadia Asparouhova — Tech elites, democracy, open source, & philanthropy
Dwarkesh Patel
39 Bethany McLean — Enron, FTX, 2008, Musk, frauds, & visionaries
Bethany McLean — Enron, FTX, 2008, Musk, frauds, & visionaries
Dwarkesh Patel
40 Holden Karnofsky — History's most important century
Holden Karnofsky — History's most important century
Dwarkesh Patel
41 $30m Grant to OpenAI?
$30m Grant to OpenAI?
Dwarkesh Patel
42 Does GPT Have Holden Worried?
Does GPT Have Holden Worried?
Dwarkesh Patel
43 Lars Doucet — Progress, poverty, Georgism, & why rent is too damn high
Lars Doucet — Progress, poverty, Georgism, & why rent is too damn high
Dwarkesh Patel
44 Deep Learning Changes Everything
Deep Learning Changes Everything
Dwarkesh Patel
45 Garett Jones — Immigration, national IQ, & less democracy
Garett Jones — Immigration, national IQ, & less democracy
Dwarkesh Patel
46 Marc Andreessen — AI, crypto, 1000 Elon Musks, regrets, vulnerabilities, & managerial revolution
Marc Andreessen — AI, crypto, 1000 Elon Musks, regrets, vulnerabilities, & managerial revolution
Dwarkesh Patel
47 Why You Shouldn't Start A Startup
Why You Shouldn't Start A Startup
Dwarkesh Patel
48 The Future Of Venture Capital
The Future Of Venture Capital
Dwarkesh Patel
49 The Crucial Skill For A Startup Founder
The Crucial Skill For A Startup Founder
Dwarkesh Patel
50 Brett Harrison — FTX US former president speaks out
Brett Harrison — FTX US former president speaks out
Dwarkesh Patel
51 Nat Friedman (Github CEO) — Reading ancient scrolls, open source, & AI
Nat Friedman (Github CEO) — Reading ancient scrolls, open source, & AI
Dwarkesh Patel
52 Ilya Sutskever (OpenAI Chief Scientist) — Why next-token prediction could surpass human intelligence
Ilya Sutskever (OpenAI Chief Scientist) — Why next-token prediction could surpass human intelligence
Dwarkesh Patel
53 Impact of Taiwan Invasion on AI
Impact of Taiwan Invasion on AI
Dwarkesh Patel
54 Reliability is Bottleneck on AI - OpenAI Founder
Reliability is Bottleneck on AI - OpenAI Founder
Dwarkesh Patel
55 Next Token Prediction SOLVES AI Says OpenAI Founder
Next Token Prediction SOLVES AI Says OpenAI Founder
Dwarkesh Patel
56 Harmful Uses of GPT - OpenAI Founder
Harmful Uses of GPT - OpenAI Founder
Dwarkesh Patel
57 Why OpenAI Founder Thinks AI Is Near
Why OpenAI Founder Thinks AI Is Near
Dwarkesh Patel
58 AI will help us achieve enlightenment -  OpenAI Founder
AI will help us achieve enlightenment - OpenAI Founder
Dwarkesh Patel
59 Eliezer Yudkowsky — Why AI will kill us, aligning LLMs, nature of intelligence, SciFi, & rationality
Eliezer Yudkowsky — Why AI will kill us, aligning LLMs, nature of intelligence, SciFi, & rationality
Dwarkesh Patel
60 Richard Rhodes — The making of the atomic bomb
Richard Rhodes — The making of the atomic bomb
Dwarkesh Patel

Related AI Lessons

Addictive AI Could Become The Next Big Business Risk
AI-driven digital products can be addictive, posing risks to mental health and customer behavior, making it a significant business concern
Forbes Innovation
AI Compliance Checklist 2026: SOC 2, HIPAA, GDPR Guide
Learn how to ensure AI compliance with major regulations like SOC 2, HIPAA, and GDPR using a comprehensive checklist
Dev.to AI
Catch AI Hallucinations Before Your Audience Does: A Validation System That Actually Works
Learn to catch AI hallucinations before your audience does with a validation system that actually works
Dev.to · binky
Anti-AI Sentiment is Destroying the Environment
Anti-AI sentiment is linked to environmental harm, highlighting the need to reassess AI's role in sustainability
Medium · Cybersecurity

Chapters (12)

Intro
0:47 AI takeover via cyber or bio
32:27 Can we coordinate against AI?
53:49 Human vs AI colonizers
1:04:55 Probability of AI takeover
1:21:56 Can we detect deception?
1:47:25 Using AI to solve coordination problems
1:56:01 Partial alignment
2:11:41 AI far future
2:23:04 Markets & other evidence
2:33:26 Day in the life of Carl Shulman
2:47:05 Space warfare, Malthusian long
Up next
Risk Management Excellence with ISO 31000 Frameworks
Coursera
Watch →