Comparing Two Eval Runs by Their Average Pass Rate Is the Wrong Test

📰 Dev.to · Maya Andersson

Comparing eval runs by average pass rate can be misleading, learn why and how to do it correctly

intermediate Published 14 Jul 2026
Action Steps
  1. Run multiple versions of your model against the same eval set to collect pass rate data
  2. Calculate the average pass rate for each model version
  3. Apply statistical tests, such as the t-test or ANOVA, to compare the pass rates of different model versions
  4. Consider using alternative metrics, like precision, recall, or F1 score, to get a more comprehensive understanding of model performance
  5. Visualize the pass rate distributions for each model version to identify potential outliers or biases
Who Needs to Know This

Data scientists and machine learning engineers can benefit from understanding the limitations of average pass rate comparisons to improve their model evaluation and selection processes.

Key Insight

💡 Comparing average pass rates can be misleading due to the potential for outliers, biases, and statistical fluctuations

Share This
Don't compare eval runs by average pass rate alone! Learn why and how to do it correctly #MachineLearning #ModelEvaluation

Key Takeaways

Comparing eval runs by average pass rate can be misleading, learn why and how to do it correctly

Full Article

TL;DR. You run version A and version B against the same 500-item eval set. A passes 71.4 percent, B...
Read full article → ← Back to Reads

Related Videos

Skip Lists: Coin Flips Instead of Rebalancing
Skip Lists: Coin Flips Instead of Rebalancing
DataMListic
Generative vs Discriminative Models - Explained
Generative vs Discriminative Models - Explained
DataMListic
Class 14 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260503 133253 Meeting Recording
Class 14 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260503 133253 Meeting Recording
Karthik Sundara Rajan
Class 13 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260426 133418 Meeting Recording
Class 13 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260426 133418 Meeting Recording
Karthik Sundara Rajan
Class 15 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260510 133228 Meeting Recording
Class 15 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260510 133228 Meeting Recording
Karthik Sundara Raajan
Class 12 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260425 133139 Meeting Recording
Class 12 Machine Learning ( S 2 25 AIMLZG 565) Prof. Kiruthiga A R 20260425 133139 Meeting Recording
Karthik Sundara Rajan